Pierce The Heart Part 5 (Jeff the killer X Reader)

You slipped on the clothes you had borrowed, giving a small stretch, taking a swift glance at the mirror, you noticed your cheeks were still tinted with the slightest of scarlet, what if Jeff had told the others about your little event.
You desperately hoped he wouldn't, after all, Jeff didn't like drama, right?


You swung the door ope-"OW!" you heard BEN yelp out, you had apparently just slammed him in the wall.


Yes! IN the wall.
He was half phased through it, and the door.
"Oof... DON'T SLAM DOORS...." He hissed out, rubbing his head.
You apologized about 50 times to the batter covered demon, then made your way downstairs.


Then you saw him
He was glaring at Jane, they had began arguing about something.
You rolled your eyes.
You swore they were idiots sometimes.
Then Jeff glanced over, and his face flushed.
Jane noted that quickly, and glanced over, a sly grin on her face
"Oh~ Hello, ____, how nice of you to join us~"
You looked over to Jeff, hoping for some way out of this whole event that was about to play out.
Alass, he only look to you with what you thought was an apologetic look,  along with his casual smile.


You never paid much attention to it, but the scars he had looked as if they were new, sirely they were too deep to fade, but you  couldn't help but wonder if he allowed them to heal fully, or if he re-made them occasionally?


Either way Jane saw you two staring at each other.


She chuckled to herself.
"Awww~ Look at you two!!"
She chimed
Jeff and You shot her a hateful glance and turned away.


"Ohhh! I know why Jeffy was blushing so bad before, by the way, Darling ____!"
Your heart lurched.
Did he tell her??


Would he?

you looked over at Jeff.

He looked as confused as you, what was she about to say?


"Clearly, you two had a *fun* night~"
You and Jeff both choked on the air in your lungs and swung around to face her
"WHAT!!??"
You both shouted,
your cheeks red.
"WE DID NOT"
Jeff growled out, his face was flushed red.


Neither of you could believe this.


Eyeless Jack had glanced out at you all from the kitchen, a black liquid was dripping from his mask.
"Shut up, geeze, you loud mouths..."
You and Jeff turned a hate filled glance on him.


"O-or not.."
He slipped back into the kitchen slowly.


You heard Jane laugh, and  turned to see Jeff sulking outside, his hoodie had been cleared of the blood that stained it at once, and when he came back, it would be splattered with red.

Yet again.

You glared at Jane once more before dashing up to Jeff's room, and laying on his bed.


His room was dark, he never had the lights on, it seemed.
And His curtains covered the window.


Then again, he wouldn't want to hurt his eyes, any more than they already were.


You lied on his bed, your stomach felt twisted when you thought about him, and what Jane said had just pissed him off.


Did that mean he didn't feel the same?


You rested your head against his pillow, and dozed off.


This morning was a wreck.

And you hoped to dream it all away.